Great colleagues but poor pay and cliquey culture - Anonymous employee Autotrader Employee Review

1.0
Jun 12, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Some good benefits - Hard-working colleagues

Cons

- Poor pay & minimal pay increases (no bonuses either, except in the form of company shares that you have to wait for maturity- at which point they are worth practically nothing) - No progression (especially within P&T) - Exclusionary & cliquey culture - Autotrader does not respond well to critical feedback (often just ignoring it altogether and pretending to listen) - Inflexible working arrangement

avatar
Autotrader Response
10h
We completely agree that our hard-working teams are one of the best parts of being here, and we're really glad you value the benefits. Please be assured that we take your comments on board. Feedback has already been helpful in the recent changes we made to our hybrid policy. As Nathan shared at the conference, this flexible approach is a permanent part of how we work.

Explore other reviews about Autotrader

5.0
Jul 10, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Work-life balance is amazing. Everyone is open to communication. You can talk about any issue with your manager without hesitating.

Cons

Everything is too structured. You cannot improve yourself too muchç

1
avatar
Autotrader Response
1y
Hi there, thanks so much your 5* review and contribution to our Glassdoor page, it's very much appreciated! Lovely to hear you find the work-life balance amazing and the open communication, music to our ears and exactly what we strive for. We also appreciate your constructive comment around structure, are you referring to a career path or the work you do? Be good to hear more and how we can help understand that. Thanks again and we hope you continue to enjoy life at AT!
1.0
Mar 11, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Whatever was good about Autotrader is long gone by now

Cons

This place is a masterclass in corporate hypocrisy. Leadership constantly congratulates itself on being “inclusive” and “people-first,” but anyone who actually works here knows that’s just branding. Feedback is supposedly encouraged, yet when employees raise real concerns, management either ignores it completely or shuts it down if it doesn’t fit their narrative. They just doesn’t listen, or don't want to. Decisions are made behind closed doors and then pushed down with the expectation that everyone should just smile and accept them. When employees try to question things or suggest improvements, they’re labeled as “not aligned with the culture.” In other words: agree with leadership and keep quiet or go home. What’s most frustrating is the huge gap between the company’s public image and the internal reality. They love talking about diversity, inclusion, and open dialogue in external messaging, but internally many employees feel unheard and sidelined. It’s hard to take those values seriously when management repeatedly proves they don’t practice them. And if you post on Glassdoor? Don't you dare! Morale is low because people feel like their voices don’t matter. The leadership team seems far more interested in protecting their image than actually fixing the issues employees keep raising.

32
avatar
Autotrader Response
2mo
We acknowledge your review and the feedback you have submitted.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All